Guide
Giving Every Child a Vote
How to share real decisions without handing over the household.
Share this
- Time in real life
- 10 minutes inside a family meeting
- Ages
- 5–18
- Reading
- 7 min
Reviewed by Sian Trombley, CCCFounder, Thrive Family Company
7 min read
Somewhere between never asking the children anything and letting a seven-year-old choose the holiday, there is a narrow, extremely useful strip of shared decision-making that most families never use.
The evidence on this is unglamorous but consistent: children who are consulted on decisions that affect them comply more readily with the decisions they were not consulted on. Voice is not the same as control, and children can tell the difference long before they can explain it.
The whole practice rests on one piece of honesty — saying, before the discussion, which kind of decision this is.
The three kinds of decision
- 01
Ours to decide
Bedtimes, safety, school attendance, money. Announced, explained, not voted on. "This one's ours. I'll tell you why, and you can tell me what you think of it, but it isn't a vote."
- 02
Ours to decide, with your input
Where we go on Saturday, how the chores are split, what the screen rule looks like. The children genuinely shape the outcome; the adults hold the pen.
- 03
Yours to decide
Pudding on Friday, the film, the order of the bedtime routine, what goes on the wall in their room. Small, real, and never quietly reversed afterwards.
Running the ten minutes
- Name the category first, in one sentence, before any discussion.
- Youngest speaks first. Otherwise the eldest sets the position and the youngest agrees with it.
- Everyone gets uninterrupted time, including whoever is least articulate. Count to three after they stop before anyone replies.
- Write the decision down where it can be seen. Unwritten decisions get relitigated on Thursday.
- If the adults have to override an input decision later, say so explicitly and give the reason. Silent reversals are the thing that breaks trust.
Age by age
Adolescents are the group that most needs this and the group most often skipped, usually because the household has learned that consulting them starts an argument. It is worth noticing that the argument is frequently about not being consulted.
A child with a voice in the small decisions argues far less about the large ones they were never going to get.
Sian Trombley
Try this week
- 01Name the decision type out loud before every family discussion this week.
- 02Move one thing from 'ours to decide' into 'yours to decide' and leave it there.
- 03Let the youngest person speak first, once.
- 04Write down one decision where everyone can see it.
- 05If you override something, say that you are doing it and why.
The therapist's perspective
Teenagers who describe home as fair almost never mean they got their way. They mean they were told the truth about how the decision was made.
If you have historically decided everything, expect the first few attempts to be met with suspicion or silence. That is not failure; it is a household checking whether the offer is real.
Sian
Founder, Thrive Family Company
Share this
Continue in Family Meetings
The Five-Minute Meeting for Impossible Weeks
The weeks a family most needs a meeting are the weeks there is no room for one. This is the stripped-back version — five minutes, standing up, still counts.
When One Parent Isn't Sold on Family Meetings
A reluctant partner is not an obstacle to work around. Here is how to have the conversation honestly — and what to do if the answer is still no.
The Meeting Where the Rules Get Rewritten
Rules set for a nine-year-old rarely fit a thirteen-year-old. Here is how to renegotiate them deliberately, before they are broken into obsolescence.